Posted by: devonfinefibres | November 4, 2008

Cotton – a price worth paying?

I saw this on the Warmwell site (see link on RHS) yesterday.

November 3 3008 ~ GM debate: “official figures from the Indian Ministry of Agriculture do indeed confirm that …more than 1,000 farmers kill themselves here each month.”

A journalist from the Daily Mail, Andrew Malone, travelled to the ’suicide belt’ in Maharashtra state.

    “…What I found was deeply disturbing – and has profound implications for countries, including Britain, debating whether to allow the planting of seeds manipulated by scientists to circumvent the laws of nature…..In village after village, families told how they had fallen into debt after being persuaded to buy GM seeds instead of traditional cotton seeds. The price difference is staggering: £10 for 100 grams of GM seed, compared with less than £10 for 1,000 times more traditional seeds…”

The article explains how traditional varieties have been banned from many government seed banks. Up to 17 million acres in India have been planted with GM but, far from being ‘magic seeds’, as poor farmers were promised, not only do GM pest-proof ‘breeds’ of cotton become devastated by bollworms, they also require double the amount of water. When crops failed in the past, farmers could still save seeds and replant them the following year but these GM seeds contain ‘terminator technology’and do not produce viable seeds of their own.”

Whatever the arguments for and against GM it’s obvious that the technology is not being used correctly in India and the result is the death of some very desperate people. It’s another reminder to us all that if we use fibres for our crafts we should always give thought to provenence. Just as nowadays most people in the UK certainly like to know where their meat has come from before eating it, we should always know as much as possible about the origin of our fibres.


Responses

  1. Well. We were just talking about the origins of the “book charkha” at our drinking and spinning group.

    Reminds you of the Mongolian cashmere crisis, doesn’t it?

  2. Yes it does. I’m very conscious of the situation in Mongolia and China of course being a cashmere producer myself but our other fibres need careful thought as well. For example – Merino wool – does it come from a flock which practises “mulesing”? Are we happy with that if it does?

    How goes election Day over the pond?

  3. I didn’t understand what mulesing was but I do now after googling the term. What a barbaric practice!

    I certainly wouldn’t be happy buying merino from such a flock but how do we find out who does what?

    Best wishes,

    Jenny in Ventnor, UK

  4. P.s. I think the GM food debate must really take notice of reports like this one. I don’t suppose for a moment that it’s been exaggerated and our politicians seem to be so blind – and deaf, too – to what people are saying against GM foods and seeds.

    Not quite yet in despair!

  5. I think finding Merino from a guaranteed “mulesing free” flock is almost impossible if you buy tops or imported Aus or NZ fibre from the usual suppliers. They are made from pooled fleece of course. The only way would be to buy direct from individual farms. You should not of course buy raw fleece – you could risk introducing any one of a number of diseases over here. But tops, yarn etc should be fine and you could then spin or knit etc with a clear conscience!
    Alternatively you could buy Bowmont of course! However, I have none left at the moment and have forward sold most of my crop for the next three years!


Leave a response

Your response:

Categories